top of page

Manufacturer, Dealer or Both (CPA Series)

Writer: Abhilash Agrawal
Abhilash Agrawal
8 hours ago
8 min read

Whom to name in a consumer complaint about a defective product


(This is the third article in our CPA Series, where we dive deep into some of the nuanced positions in the Consumer Protection law of India. Every week, we come out with a new article. Please subscribe to keep track of the latest in BLC Insights!)


A refrigerator bought from the neighbourhood showroom stops cooling within a month. A new scooter develops an engine knock soon after its first service at the authorised dealer. A gold chain from a retail store tests below the purity on its tag, steel bars from a local distributor rust before they are used, and a car arrives with kilometres already on its odometer. In most of these cases the problem is sorted out at the counter or the service centre. Only a small share of such grievances ever reaches a Consumer Commission.


When one does, the first question that comes up while drafting the complaint is a simple one: whom should the buyer name? The buyer usually paid the dealer, but the product carries the brand of the manufacturer, and the warranty card often bears the manufacturer’s name. Naming the wrong party, or leaving out the right one, can cost the buyer time and sometimes the relief itself.


This piece is relevant to buyers deciding whom to proceed against, to dealers and distributors who are often the first to receive a notice, and to manufacturers who are joined to complaints about transactions they never handled.


Why the Act cares about who the seller is


The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 (“Act”) protects a “consumer”, and under Section 2(7) a consumer of goods is a person who buys goods for a consideration (along with any user of those goods with the buyer’s approval). The definition is built around a transaction. The person who sold the goods and received the price is, in the ordinary course, the person against whom the buyer has a contractual claim. Usually the manufacturer sells to a dealer, who sells to the buyer, with no direct contract between the buyer and the manufacturer.


This matters because most dealership and distributorship agreements state that the dealer buys and resells the goods on its own account, as a principal, and not as the agent of the manufacturer. An agent’s acts bind the principal. A dealer who deals on a principal-to-principal basis answers for its own acts, and the manufacturer does not automatically answer for them.


The Act, however, does not leave the manufacturer out of the picture where the product itself is at fault. Chapter VI (Sections 82 to 87) creates a “product liability action” for harm caused by a defective product, which may be brought against a product manufacturer, a product service provider or a product seller. Under Section 84(1)(a), a product manufacturer is liable where “the product contains a manufacturing defect”, among other grounds such as design defects, deviation from specifications, non-conformity to an express warranty and inadequate instructions or warnings. Section 86 sets out when a seller who is not the manufacturer is liable.


Section 86 provides as follows:

“A product seller who is not a product manufacturer shall be liable in a product liability action, if-

(d) the product has been sold by him and the identity of product manufacturer of such product is not known, or if known, the service of notice or process or warrant cannot be effected on him or he is not subject to the law which is in force in India or the order, if any, passed or to be passed cannot be enforced against him; or …”


The other clauses of Section 86 make the seller liable where it exercised substantial control over the design, manufacture, packaging or labelling of the product, altered or modified it, gave its own express warranty, or failed to take reasonable care in assembling, inspecting or maintaining the product or to pass on the manufacturer’s warnings. The scheme is therefore clear in its logic: the manufacturer answers for what goes wrong in the making of the product, and the seller answers for what goes wrong in its own handling of the product and of the sale. Chapter VI deals with “harm” caused by a defective product, but the same logic runs through ordinary complaints of defect and deficiency in service as well.


The principal-to-principal defence


The leading authority is Indian Oil Corporation v. Consumer Protection Council, Kerala & Anr. (SCI, 1993), where the Hon’ble Supreme Court read the dealership agreement between the oil company and its LPG distributor and held that the relationship was one of principal to principal, so that the oil company was not answerable for the distributor’s dealings with consumers. The Hon’ble National Commission has applied that decision in later cases. In Indian Oil Corporation Limited v. Shri Hansmukhbhai M. Patel & Ors. (NCDRC, 2012), a complaint arising out of an LPG fire had been allowed by the Hon’ble Gujarat State Commission against the oil company and the other opposite parties jointly. In the oil company’s first appeal, the Hon’ble National Commission, respectfully following the Supreme Court, found that “there was no privity of contract between the IOC and the consumer” and set aside the order against the oil company.


The defence was considered in detail in Tata Motors Limited v. Antonio Paulo Vaz & Anr. (SCI, 2021). The buyer had paid the full price of a new car, but the dealer delivered a vehicle of an older make which had already travelled some distance and showed defects. The District Forum, North Goa, held the manufacturer and the dealer jointly and severally liable. The Hon’ble Goa State Commission dismissed the manufacturer’s appeal, and the Hon’ble National Commission dismissed its revision petition in Tata Motors Limited v. Antonio Paulo Vaz & Anr. (NCDRC, 2020), rejecting the principal-to-principal plea.


The Hon’ble Supreme Court allowed the manufacturer’s appeal. It noted that the dealership agreement expressly appointed the dealer on a principal-to-principal basis and disclaimed any agency, and that the manufacturer had not sold the car to the buyer. It held:

“Unless the manufacturer’s knowledge is proved, a decision fastening liability upon the manufacturer would be untenable, given that its relationship with the dealer, in the facts of this case, were on principal-to-principal basis.”


The findings against the dealer, which had stayed away from the proceedings, were not disturbed, and the buyer was left free to execute the refund against it. The lesson is not that a manufacturer can never be liable for a dealer’s conduct, but that where the grievance is about the dealer’s own acts (the wrong vehicle, an overcharge, a delayed delivery, a false promise at the counter), the buyer must plead and prove the manufacturer’s knowledge or involvement if he/she wants relief against the manufacturer.


When both answer to the buyer


The position is different where the complaint is about the product itself. A manufacturing defect is, by its nature, the manufacturer’s doing, and Commissions routinely hold the manufacturer liable even though it did not sell directly to the buyer. In Tayal India Motors Private Limited v. Jogender Sharma Through LRs & Ors. (NCDRC, 2024), the vehicle needed repeated repairs within days of purchase. The District Forum, Faridabad, ordered replacement or a joint and several refund, and the Hon’ble Haryana State Commission dismissed the appeals of both the manufacturer and the dealer. In their revision petitions, the Hon’ble National Commission observed that “When a consumer buys a vehicle, he expects it to be free of defects and in good working order”, held that it made no difference whether the fault lay with the manufacturer or the dealer, and held both jointly and severally liable for selling a defective vehicle, while modifying the relief to a refund.


Commissions have also looked at who should finally bear the loss. In Ningappa Hanamanppa Kador Dadda Gubbi v. Hindustan Motors Limited (NCDRC, 2010), the Hon’ble Karnataka State Commission had kept the dealer jointly and severally liable as the seller, but placed the principal liability for the manufacturing defect on the manufacturer, leaving the dealer to recover from the manufacturer what it paid. The Hon’ble National Commission found no inconsistency in that approach and dismissed the buyer’s revision petition.


Under the Act, dealers have found it equally difficult to shelter behind the manufacturer. In M/s Go Green Bikes v. Anita Sood & Anr. (SCDRC, 2025), the dealer of an electric two-wheeler argued that a defective motor was the manufacturer’s responsibility. The Hon’ble Chandigarh State Commission held that a dealer who sold the product, received the price and assured after-sales service was a product seller and service provider under the Act, and that it “cannot wash off its liability by merely shifting the blame upon the manufacturer”. It also held that the dealership agreement and the disputes between the dealer and the manufacturer did not bind the buyer.


These decisions turn on their facts. Tata Motors (2021) did not hold that a manufacturer is never liable for what happens at the dealership, and Tayal India Motors (2024) did not hold that a dealer is always liable for a manufacturing defect. What each forum did was to ask whose act or omission caused the grievance, and whether the party before it had any role in it.


Precautions for the buyer


The first step is to separate the grievance into its parts. If the complaint is about the product (it does not work, it is unsafe, it does not match the specification), the manufacturer is a necessary party and the seller is ordinarily joined as well. If the complaint is about the sale or the service (a different product was delivered, the price charged was more than agreed, the delivery was delayed, the repair was botched), the dealer or service centre is the primary party, and the manufacturer should be joined only where there are facts showing its knowledge or involvement.


The second step is to collect the documents that show who did what: the invoice (which shows who received the price), the warranty card (which shows who gave the warranty), the job cards from the service centre, and the correspondence.


The third step is to write to both the seller and the manufacturer before going to the Commission, describing the problem and asking for it to be put right. A manufacturer who was told of the defect and did nothing is in a weaker position to say it knew nothing, and a written record of the exchange answers the “knowledge” point that the Supreme Court found missing in Tata Motors (2021).


The fourth step is to name the correct parties at the outset, with their correct legal names and addresses. A party can be added later, but that takes time and may invite an objection of limitation from the party added. Naming both parties where the facts support it also guards against the situation Section 86(d) addresses: where the manufacturer cannot be identified, served or reached under Indian law, the seller who sold the product may itself be answerable.


Conclusion


The question of whom to sue is not a technicality. The Act links the consumer’s claim to the transaction and to the cause of the grievance, and the decisions above show that Commissions will look at both. A manufacturer will, and should, answer for a defect in what it made, whether or not it sold the product directly; a dealer will answer for its own conduct of the sale and for the product it put into the buyer’s hands. What a buyer cannot expect is that a manufacturer will be held liable for a dealer’s independent acts merely because its name is on the product.


Next week: bought in the company’s name, and who can file the consumer complaint.


Please subscribe to keep track of the latest in this CPA Series!


This update is for general information only and is not legal advice.


Feel free to reach out to us with your queries at legal@benevolentlawchambers.com

Recent Posts

See All
Tested, but not proven (CPA Series)

Precautions while relying on a laboratory test report in a consumer complaint. The first article in our CPA Series on the consumer protection law of India.

 
 
 

Comments


Subscribe to our updates

bottom of page